• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Welcome to Prince Umberto Pizzeria

Prince Umberto Pizzeria, located at 1910 Wantagh Ave, Wantagh, NY, is a cherished gem for pizza lovers seeking authentic New York-style pies. Known for its crispy thin crust and flavorful sauce, this pizzeria offers an inviting, no-frills atmosphere perfect for a quick bite. Customers rave about the vodka grandma pie, regular and Sicilian slices, and delicious entrees like pasta dishes and chicken parm. Friendly staff and prompt service add to the experience, making it a local favorite. Prince Umberto Pizzeria embodies the essence of classic pizza dining, focusing on quality ingredients and satisfying flavors without pretension.

Prince Umberto Pizzeria: Reviews & Ratings

ABurntMuffin
ABurntMuffin

The only New York hole in the wall pizza joint you'll find in this town that isn't ran by stoned teenagers. People putting 1 star reviews saying their pizza is "doughy" are straight up lying. If you think your Sicilian slice isn't going to be doughier than a regular, well then you've got water on the brain. I don't go anywhere else for a regular slice. Not pretending to be an Italian restaurant, not pretending to be a hangout or a club or some millennial coffee shop. It's just good old New York style crispy hot cheesy pizza. Their fried cappilinis and rice balls and chicken rolls and pinwheels are also bomb. Garlic knots are what you expect, dough garlic and oil. People really be expecting Michelin star soy boy pizza. Don't come here if you're looking for a 50 dollar slice deconstructed and plated to look like your family home. You won't find it. Come here for bread sauce cheese and the occasional bit of chicken or meatball and you'll never be disappointed. Staff is wonderful, ambience is what you want from an in-and-out pizza joint.

MR HANDS ON
MR HANDS ON

Great tasting pizza. A crispy thin crust with a very flavorful sauce makes this pie unbelievable. Would recommended highly especially on Wednesdays when they have an amazing offer. Call to find out their pizza special!!

Nicholas Magno
Nicholas Magno

This place is on point! The pizza is great, we especially love the vodka grandma pie. And there entrees are amazing too. The pasta dishes are always perfect. The staff is very friendly and never takes too long to get your food. Only pizza place we go to in this area!

Billy E
Billy E

My favorite pizza place. I live in Seaford, but will go here, or have them deliver when its my turn to order pizza. The guys who work here are all very. Prices are very reasonable. Delivery is always, accurate, on-time or sometimes a little early. I highly recommend their grandma pie...hate to admit it, but I could probably eat an entire pie myself...the slices are light and go down easy. Im also a fan of their regular and Sicilian pies. My daughter likes their white pie and the chicken parm pie is another new favorite of my family.

Middle Passage Consulting
Middle Passage Consulting

I ordered a delivery in Cambria Heights. Lobster bisque and a extra cheese half pepperoni pizza. Oh my God!! Because I order through Grub Hub, in the delivery section, I put that we're older women so please call or knock. The young woman who brought our order went beyond the call of duty and what a cheerful smile. Don't miss out! Order from this place!!!

Lisa S
Lisa S

Love their pizza. They have a nice special for January for pick up. Always fits the bill for a last minute pizza party.

Max Cohn
Max Cohn

Solid place to grab a slice, staff is very helpful!

Karen F
Karen F

I love this place... Been going here for years and highly recommend you try it. This is my "go to" place for Grandma Pizza! It's delicious! I also love their Margherita Pizza. My husband loves their regular pizza (but usually gets it with mushrooms or pepperoni). Their crust is flavorful and delicious - which is so important for good pizza.

Location

Welcome to Prince Umberto Pizzeria, a beloved gem nestled at 1910 Wantagh Ave, Wantagh, NY. Known for serving genuine New York-style pizza, this pizzeria is the go-to spot for those craving a slice of classic comfort food. Renowned for its crispy, thin crust and flavorful sauce, Prince Umberto’s has garnered a loyal following among local pizza enthusiasts.

The charm of this establishment lies in its authenticity. As one reviewer aptly put it, "It’s just good old New York style crispy hot cheesy pizza." No pretensions here—just delicious, satisfying slices that hit the spot every time. Their menu ranges from traditional regular and Sicilian pies to delightful innovations like the vodka grandma pie, a crowd favorite that keeps patrons coming back for more.

Additionally, the offerings extend beyond pizza; dishes such as fried cappellini, rice balls, chicken rolls, and pinwheels only enhance the overall experience. Even the garlic knots are a testament to the skill and care taken in the kitchen—perfectly doughy and bursting with garlicky goodness. You won’t find any trendy deconstructed plating here, just a wholesome dining experience for those who appreciate the simplicity of quality ingredients.

Prince Umberto Pizzeria truly shines in its customer service as well. With a staff that’s as welcoming as their food is delicious, every visit feels like dining among friends. Whether you choose to dine in or opt for delivery, you can always expect prompt service with a cheerful smile—a detail that adds warmth to every meal.

If you’re in the Wantagh area, make it a point to stop by this charming pizzeria. You’ll quickly understand why so many locals consider it their favorite. As one fan succinctly professed, “Only pizza place we go to in this area!” With its reasonable prices, generous portions, and a menu crafted to please both traditionalists and adventurous eaters alike, Prince Umberto Pizzeria is a must-try for anyone seeking a slice of New York’s pizza heritage.